Skip to main content

Best American Restaurant in Matamoras

Randy's wings, Shane's table, Matamoras' favorite spot
Award Winning Wings

Award Winning Wings

Start with the wings, then take your pick from burgers, steaks, seafood, sandwiches, and weekly specials.
The Bar

The Bar

Settle in for craft cocktails, beer, wine, and an easygoing night at the bar.
Catering and Trays To Go

Catering and Trays To Go

Bring Mr. Shane’s to your gathering with catering, trays to go, and events at the restaurant.

Delicious lunch stop on our way to NYC. It's in the hotel, so there's plenty of parking and lots of space in the restaurant. We sat outside, and it was lovely. The food was top notch, too, and worth the $100 ticket for 2 adults and 3 kids eating lobster rolls, flatbread, and cheesecake. Highly recommend, and we'll be back if we're ever up here again!

Laura H.

My boyfriend and I enjoyed our experience and food so much, it exceeded our expectations. It was the first time we tried a lobster roll and it was so good, we got it hot. We opted in for truffle fries instead of regular ones, highly recommend. I had to try to pickles fries I would say 8/10, I had to just try them because I love pickles. My boyfriend on the other hand doesn’t like pickles at all and tried them and said they were okay. I liked them. We tried a little bit of everything from the…

Hailey N.

I Spent the week at the Best western for work. I had dinner the first night at Mr. Shane’s. The food was delicious and I was treated like a regular the min I walked in…… to thank them for the service and hospitality I had lunch and dinner there the rest of my stay. Great food across the menu, paired with the hospitality only seen at your favorite relatives or grandmas house. Kudos to Heather and Taylor.

Tyler M.

Shane did our wedding and we were excited to here he was opening up this place after the wedding. The food was amazing, and the drinks were on point. Shane followed up with every guest and asked how the family and kids were doing, as a great Manager should, and his staff was incredible. Always cool to see Randy as well. Prices were fair for thus day and age, and 100% worth it, with the cost of everything going up. Wings were thick, tasty, and crispy, we had the mango habanero. I had the wagyu…

Jovanie G.

I don’t usually write reviews… but this place deserves its flowers 💐🔥 From the second you walk in, the vibe is already a 10/10. The food? Unreal. Like the kind of good where you take one bite and just sit there for a second like “yeah… this is it.” Everything was fresh, flavorful, and made with real love — not just thrown together. And let’s talk about the service 👏🏽 — attentive without being overbearing, super welcoming, and just all-around good energy. You can tell they actually care…

Erika S.

Mr. Shane's Restaurant Rewards

Mr. Shane's Restaurant Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?
What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout

Where are you located?

We are located in Matamoras, PA at 120 US-6 #209

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Matamoras, Duttonville, Tristates, Port Jervis, Westfall, Sparrow Bush, Montague, Millrift, Milford, Mongaup, Knights Eddy, Logtown, Huguenot, Shin Hollow, Greenville, Colesville, Cahoonzie, Rockport, Waterloo Mills, and Shaytown.

Our location

Map showing the location of Mr. Shane's Restaurant on 120 US-6 #209 in Matamoras
Loading today's hours...